Two presenters, four cuts each: 9:16 and 4:5, with and without the price line. Simon is the re-rendered version; Revard is the approved one, unchanged.
Unchanged from the version you approved. Same master, same cuts.
Re-rendered so the face carries his own detail instead of the generator's averages.
Both panels are cropped by the same rule: panel width = 3.2 × the distance between the pupils. The only difference left on screen is the likeness itself.
Every frame is scored against that presenter's own photos, never against the other presenter. Likeness is a 1.00-scale score where his real photographs are the reference.
| master | likeness (1.00 = his own photos) | face h/w | jaw width | skin ΔE | interocular px | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Real Simon (4 photos) | 1.000 | 1.59 | 1.64 | 0 | — | ground truth |
| Simon v3 (the version that looked off) | 0.870 | 1.67 | 1.47 | 6.8 | 160 | what we replaced |
| Simon v5 (this delivery) | 0.887 | 1.65 | 1.32 | 6.3 | 253 | closer, still short |
| Revard v3 (approved) | 0.944 | 1.59 | 1.89 | 13.6 | 259 | the bar we had to reach |
Where it stands. Simon's likeness measures 0.887 against his own photographs, up from 0.870 on the version you flagged. The approved Revard master measures 0.944. The target we set ourselves was 0.95, so Simon is closer but not there yet. The framing is fixed — his face now fills half the frame width, exactly like Revard's — and the cheek and brow detail is his own rather than averaged. What is still off is jaw and cheek width: the render comes out at 1.32 units wide where his photographs measure 1.64. That is the generator narrowing the face, and it needs a geometry pass on the jaw before we call it done. Ship these or wait for that pass — your call.
Read this before publishing. The "no price" cuts remove the price from the end card only — the spoken audio is the approved take and still says the monthly figure. If a price-free spot has to be price-free in audio too, that needs a fresh voice take, not a re-cut.
Everything else is final: 1080×1920 and 1080×1350, 30 fps, audio normalised to −16 LUFS, 597 frames colour- and geometry-matched on Simon's master.